嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈��
源平慎弌傍利 卦指云慕朕村 紗秘慕禰 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 〆辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂〇

my name is red-厘議兆忖出碕-及7何蛍

酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何! 泌惚云慕短嗤堋響頼���誅卒亮茂�俊彭堋響��辛聞喘貧圭 "辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂" 孔嬬 才 "紗秘慕禰" 孔嬬��


Shekure¨s letter wasn¨t meant for Hasan�察�but for someone else。 What did the 
letter  say�拭 �Esther  was  mad  with  curiosity�察 �and  in  the  end�察 �I  did  succeed  in 
reading it。 
But alas�察�we don¨t know each other that well�察�do we�拭�To be honest�察�I was 
overe with embarrassment and worry。 How I read the letter you¨ll never 
know。  Maybe  you¨ll  shame  and  belittle  me  for  my  meddling!as  if  you 
yourselves aren¨t as nosy as barbers。 I¨ll just relate to you what I learned from 
reading the letter。 This is what sweet Shekure had written�此�
 
41 
 
Black Effendi�察�you¨re a visitor to my house thanks to your close relations with 
my father。 But don¨t expect a nod from me。 Much has happened since you left。 I 
was wed�察�and have two strong and spirited sons。 One of them is Orhan�察�he¨s the 
one whom you saw just now e to the workshop。 While I¨ve been awating the 
return of my husband these four years�察�little else has entered my thoughts。 I might 
feel lonely�察�hopeless and weak living with my two children and an elderly father。 I 
miss the strength and protection of a man�察�but let no one assume he might take 
advantage of my situation。 Therefore�察�it would please me if you ceased calling on 
us。  You  did  embarrass  me  once  before�察 �and  afterward�察 �I  had  to  endure  much 
suffering to regain my honor in my father¨s eyes� �Along with this letter�察�I¨m also 
returning  the  picture  you  painted  and  sent  to  me  when  you  were  an  impulsive 
youth  with  his  wits  not  yet  about  him。  I  do  this  so  you  won¨t  harbor  any  false 
hopes  or  misread  any  signs。  It¨s  a  mistake  to  believe  that  one  could  fall  in  love 
gazing at a picture。 It¨d be best if you stopped ing to our house pletely。 
 
My poor Shekure�察�you¨re neither a nobleman nor a pasha with a fancy seal 
to stamp your letter� �At the bottom of the page�察�she signed the first letter of 
her name�察�which looked like a small�察�frightened bird。 Nothing more。 
I said ^seal。 ̄ You¨re probably wondering how I open and close these wax´
sealed  letters。  But  in  fact  the  letters  aren¨t  sealed  at  all。  ^That  Esther  is  an 
illiterate  Jew�察院 �my  dear  Shekure  had  assumed。  ^She¨ll  never  understand  my 
writing。 ̄ True�察�I can¨t read what¨s written�察�but I can always have someone else 
read it。 And as for what¨s not written�察�I can quite readily ^read ̄ that myself。 
Confused�察�are you�拭�
Let  me  put  it  this  way�察 �so  even  the  most  thick´headed  of  you  will 
understand�此�
A letter doesn¨t municate by words alone。 A letter�察�just like a book�察�can 
be read by smelling it�察�touching it and fondling it。 Thereby�察�intelligent folk will 
say�察 �Go on then�察�read what the letter tells you� 院�whereas the dull´witted will 
say�察 �Go on then�察�read what he¨s written� 院�Listen�察�now�察�to what else Shekure 
said�此�
 
1。  Though  I¨ve  sent  this  letter  in  secret�察 �by  relying  on  Esther�察 �who¨s  made 
letter´delivery a matter of merce and custom�察�I¨m signifying that I don¨t 
intend to conceal that much at all。 
42 
 
2。  That  I¨ve  folded  it  up  like  a  French  pastry  implies  secrecy  and  mystery�察�
true。  But  the  letter  isn¨t  sealed  and  there¨s  a  huge  picture  enclosed。  The 
apparent implication is�察 �Pray�察�keep our secret at all costs�察院�which more befits 
an invitation to love than a letter of rebuke。 
3。  Furthermore�察 �the  smell  of  the  letter  confirms  this  interpretation。  The 
fragrance was faint enough to be ambiguous!did she intentionally perfume 
the letter�拭�yet alluring enough to fire readers¨ curiosity!is this the aroma of 
attar  or  the  smell  of  her  hand�拭 �And  a  fragrance�察 �which  was  enough  to 
enrapture the poor man who read the letter to me�察�will surely have the same 
effect on Black。 
4。  I  am  Esther�察 �who  knows  neither  how  to  read  nor  write�察 �but  this  I  do 
know�此�Although the flow of the script and the handwriting seems to say ^Alas�察�
I  am  rushed�察 �I  am  writing  carelessly  and  without  paying  serious  attention�察院�
these  letters  that  twitter  elegantly  as  if  caught  in  a  gentle  breeze  convey  the 
exact opposite message。 Even her phrase ^just now e ̄ when referring to 
Orhan�察 �implying  that  the  letter  was  written  at  that  very  moment�察 �betrays  a 
ploy no less obvious than care taken in each line。 
5。  The  picture  sent  along  with  the  letter  depicts  pretty  Shirin  gazing  at 
handsome H┨srev¨s image and falling in love�察�as told in the story that even I�察�
Esther  the  Jewess�察 �know  well。  All  the  lovelorn  ladies  of  Istanbul  adore  this 
story�察�but never have I known someone to send an illustration relating to it。 
 
It  happens  all  the  time  to  you  fortunate  literate  people�此 �A  maiden  who 
can¨t  read  begs  you  to  read  a  love  letter  she¨s  received。  The  letter  is  so 
surprising�察�exciting and disturbing that its owner�察�though embarrassed at your 
being privy to her most intimate affairs�察�ashamed and distraught�察�asks you 
all the same to read it once more。 You read it again。 In the end�察�you¨ve read the 
letter so many times that both of you have memorized it。 Before long�察�she¨ll 
take the letter in her hands and ask�察 �Did he make that statement there�拭院�and 
^Did he say that here�拭院�As you point to the appropriate places�察�she¨ll pore over 
those passages�察�still unable to make sense of the words there。 As she stares at 
the curvy letters of the words�察�sometimes I am so moved I forget that I myself 
can¨t read or write and feel the urge to embrace those illiterate maidens whose 
tears fall to the page。 
Then there are those truly accursed letter´readers�察�pray�察�don¨t you turn out 
to be like one of them�此�When the maiden takes the letter in her own hands to 
touch it again�察�desiring to look at it without understanding which words were 
43 
 
spoken  where�察 �these  beasts  will  say  to  her�察  �What  are  you  trying  to  do�拭 �You 
can¨t  read�察 �what  more  do  you  want  to  look  at�拭院 �Some  of  them  won¨t  even 
return the letter�察�treating it henceforth as if it belonged to them。 At times�察�the 
task of accosting them and retrieving the letter falls to me�察�Esther。 That¨s the 
kind of good woman I am。 If Esther likes you�察�she¨ll e to your aid as well。 
 
 
   
44 
 
I�察�SHEKURE 
 
Oh�察 �why  was  I  there  at  the  window  just  when  Black  rode  by  on  his  white 
steed�拭�Why did I open the shutters intuitively at that exact moment and stare 
at  him  so  long  from  behind  the  snowy  branches  of  the  pomegranate  tree�拭 �I 
can¨t  tell  you  for  sure。  I¨d  sent  word  to  Esther  by  way  of  Hayriye。  I  was�察 �of 
course�察�well aware that Black would take that route。 Meanwhile�察�I¨d gone up 
alone  to  the  room  with  the  built´in  closet  and  the  window  facing  the 
pomegranate tree to inspect the sheets  in the chest。 On a whim�察�and at just 
the  right  moment�察 �I  pushed  the  shutters  open  with  all  my  strength  and 
sunlight flooded the room�此�Standing at the window�察�I came face´to´face with 
Black�察�who�察�like the sun�察�dazzled me。 Oh�察�it was quite lovely。 
He¨d grown and matured and�察�having lost his awkward youthful lankiness�察�
he turned out to be a ely man。 Listen Shekure�察�my heart did tell me�察�he¨s 
not  only  handsome�察 �look  into  his  eyes�察 �he  possesses  the  heart  of  a  child�察 �so 
pure�察�so alone�此�Marry him。 I�察�however�察�sent him a letter wherein I¨d given him 
quite the opposite message。 
Though he was twelve years my elder�察�when I was twelve�察�I was more mature 
than he。 Back then�察�instead of standing straight and tall before me in a fashion 
befitting  a  man  and  announcing  that  he  was  going  to  do  this  or  that�察 �jump 
from this spot or climb onto that thing�察�he¨d just bury his face in some book 
or picture�察�hiding as if everything embarrassed him。 In time�察�he also fell in love 
with me。 He made a painting declaring his love。 We¨d both matured by then。 
When I turned twelve�察�I sensed that Black could no longer look into my eyes�察�
as  if  he  were  afraid  I¨d  discover  he  loved  me。  ^Hand  me  that  ivory´handled 
knife�察院�he¨d say�察�for example�察�looking at the knife but unable to look at me。 If I 
asked  him�察 �for  instance�察  �Is  the  cherry  sherbet  to  your  liking�拭院 �he  couldn¨t 
simply indicate so with a delicate smile or nod�察�as we do when our mouths are 
full�察�you see。 Instead�察�he¨d scream ^Yes ̄ at the top of his lungs�察�as if trying to 
municate  with  a  deaf  man。  He  feared  looking  me  in  the  face。  I  was  a 
maiden of striking beauty then。 Any man who caught sight of me even once�察�
from afar�察�or from between parted curtains or yawning doors�察�or even through 
the layers of my modest head coverings�察�immediately became enamored of me。 
I¨m  not  being  a  braggart�察 �I¨m  explaining  this  so  you¨ll  understand  my  story 
and be better able to share in my grief。 
In the well´known tale of H┨srev and Shirin�察�there¨s a moment that Black 
and I had discussed at length。 H┨srev¨s friend�察�Shapur�察�intends to make H┨srev 
and Shirin fall in love。 One day Shirin embarks on a countryside outing with 
45 
 
her  ladies  of  the  court�察 �when  she  sees  a  picture  of  H┨srev  that  Shapur  has 
secretly  hung  from  the  branch  of  one  of  the  trees  beneath  which  the  outing 
party has stopped to rest。 Beholding this picture of the handsome H┨srev in 
that  beautiful  garden�察 �Shirin  is  stricken  by  love。  Many  paintings  depict  this 
moment!or ^scene ̄ as the miniaturists would have it!consisting of Shirin¨s 
look  of  adoration  and  bewilderment  as  she  gazes  upon  the  image  of  H┨srev。 
While  Black  was  working  with  my  father�察 �he¨d  seen  this  picture  many  times 
and  had  twice  made  exact  copies  by  eyeing  the  original  as  he  painted。  After 
falling in love with me�察�he made a copy for himself。 But this time in place of 
H┨srev  and  Shirin�察 �he  portrayed  himself  and  me�察 �Black  and  Shekure。  If  it 
weren¨t for the captions beneath the figures�察�only I would¨ve known who the 
man and maiden in the picture were�察�because sometimes when we were joking 
around�察�he¨d depict us in the same manner and color�此�I all in blue�察�he all in 
red。  And  if  this  weren¨t  indication  enough�察 �he¨d  also  written  our  names 
beneath the figures。 He¨d left the painting where I would find it and run off。 
He watched me to see what my reaction to his position would be。 
I  was  well  aware  that  I  wouldn¨t  be  able  to  love  him  like  a  Shirin�察 �so  I 
feigned ignorance。 On the evening of that summer¨s day when Black gave me 
his  painting�察 �during  which  we¨d  tried  to  cool  ourselves  with  sour´cherry 
sherbets  made  with  ice  said  to  have  been  brought  all  the  way  from  snow´
capped Mount Ulu�察�I told my father that he¨d made a declaration of love。 At 
that  time�察 �Black  had  just  graduated  from  the  religious  school。  He  taught  in 
remote neighborhoods and�察�more out of my father¨s insistence than his own 
desire�察 �Black  was  attempting  to  obtain  the  patronage  of  the  powerful  and 
esteemed  Naim  Pasha。  But  according  to  my  father�察 �Black  didn¨t  yet  have  his 
wits  about  him。  My  father�察 �who¨d  taken  great  pains  to  win  Black  a  place  in 
Naim  Pasha¨s  circle�察 �at  least  as  a  clerk  to  begin�察 �plained  that  he  wasn¨t 
doing  much  to  further  his  own  cause�察 �in  other  words�察 �Black  was  being  an 
ignoramus。  And  that  very  night  in  reference  to  Black  and  me�察 �my  father 
declared�察 �I think he¨s set his sights very high�察�this impoverished nephew�察院�and 
without regard for my mother¨s presence�察�he added�察 �he¨s smarter than we¨d 
supposed。 ̄ 
I remember with misery what my father did in the following days�察�how I 
kept my distance from Black and how he ceased to visit our house�察�but I won¨t 
explain all of this for fear that you¨ll dislike my father and me。 I swear to you�察�
we had no other choice。 You know how in such situations reasonable people 
immediately   sense   that   love   without   hope   is   simply   hopeless�察  �and 
understanding the limits of the illogical realm of the heart�察�make a quick end 
46 
 
of it by politely declaring�察 �They didn¨t find us suitably matched。 That¨s just 
the way it is。 ̄ But�察�I¨ll have you know that my mother said several times�察 �At 
least  don¨t  break  the  boy¨s  heart。 ̄  Black�察 �whom  my  mother  referred  to  as  a 
^boy�察院�was twenty´four�察�and I was half his age。 Because my father considered 
Black¨s  declaration  of  love  an  act  of  insolence�察 �he  wouldn¨t  humor  my 
mother¨s wishes。 
Though we hadn¨t forgotten him altogether by the time we received news 
that  he¨d  left  Istanbul�察 �we¨d  let  him  slip  pletely  out  of  our  affections。 
Because we hadn¨t received news about him from any city for years�察�I deemed 
it appropriate to save the picture he¨d made and shown me�察�as a token of our 
childhood  memories  and  friendship。  To  prevent  my  father�察 �and  later  my 
soldier´husband�察 �from  discovering  the  picture  and  getting  upset  or  jealous�察 �I 
expertly  concealed  the  names  ^Shekure ̄  and  ^Black ̄  beneath  the  figures  by 
making it appear as if someone had dribbled my father¨s Hasan Pasha ink onto 
them�察�in an accident later to be disguised as flowers。 Since I¨ve returned that 
picture to him today�察�maybe those among you inclined to take a dim view of 
how I revealed myself to him at the window will feel ashamed and reconsider 
your prejudices somewhat。 
Having exposed my face to him�察�I remained for a while there at the window�察�
showered  in  the  crimson  hue  of  the  evening  sun�察 �and  gazed  in  awe  at  the 
garden bathed in reddish´orange light�察�until I felt the chill of the evening air。 
There was no breeze。 I didn¨t care what someone passing in the street would¨ve 
said  upon  seeing  me  at  the  open  window。  One  of  Ziver  Pasha¨s  daughters�察�
Mesrure�察�who always laughed and enjoyed herself saying the most surprising 
things at the most inopportune times when we went merrily and playfully to 
the public baths each week�察�once told me that a person never knows exactly 
what she herself is thinking。 This is what I know�此�Sometimes I¨ll say something 
and realize upon uttering it that it is of my own thinking�察�but no sooner do I 
arrive at that realization than I¨m convinced the very opposite is true。 
I  was  sorry  when  poor  Elegant  Effendi�察 �one  of  the  miniaturists  my  father 
often  invited  to  the  house!and  I  won¨t  pretend  I  haven¨t  spied  on  each  of 
them!went missing�察�much like my unfortunate husband。 ^Elegant ̄ was the 
ugliest among them and the most impoverished of spirit。 
I closed the shutters�察�left the room and went down to the kitchen。 
^Mother�察 �Shevket  didn¨t  listen  to  you�察院 �Orhan  said。  ^While  Black  was 
taking his horse out of the stable�察�Shevket left the kitchen and spied on him 
from the peephole。 ̄ 
47 
 
^What  of  it� 院 �Shevket  said�察 �waving  his  hand  in  the  air。  ^Mother  spied  on 
him from the hole in the closet。 ̄ 
^Hayriye�察院 �I  said。  ^
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��1�� 家��2��
酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何!
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��