嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈��
源平慎弌傍利 卦指云慕朕村 紗秘慕禰 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 〆辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂〇

my name is red-厘議兆忖出碕-及18何蛍

酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何! 泌惚云慕短嗤堋響頼���誅卒亮茂�俊彭堋響��辛聞喘貧圭 "辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂" 孔嬬 才 "紗秘慕禰" 孔嬬��


possibility of my own death came to mind。 
A crow alighted beside me。 I gazed lovingly into Black¨s eyes and asked him 
to take my arm and acpany me on the way back。 I told him I expected him 
at the house early the next morning to continue working on the book。 I had 
indeed imagined my own death�察�and realized�察�once again�察�that the book must 
be pleted�察�whatever the cost。 
 
 
   
107 
 
I WILL BE CALLED A MURDERER 
 
They threw cold�察�muddy earth onto the battered and disfigured corpse of ill´
fated Elegant Effendi and I wept more than any of them。 I shouted�察 �I want to 
die with him� 院�and ^Let me share his grave� 院�and they held me by the waist so 
I wouldn¨t fall in。 I gasped for air and they pressed their palms to my forehead�察�
drawing  my  head  back  so  I  might  breathe。  By  the  glances  of  the  deceased¨s 
relatives�察 �I  sensed  I  might  have  exaggerated  my  sobs  and  wailing�察 �I  pulled 
myself together。 Based upon my excessive sorrow the workshop gossips might 
suppose that Elegant Effendi and I had been in love。 
I  hid  behind  a  plane  tree  until  the  funeral  ended  to  avoid  drawing  more 
attention to myself。 A relative of the oaf I¨d sent to Hell!an even bigger idiot 
than  the  deceased!discovered  me  behind  the  tree  and  stared  deep  into  my 
eyes with a look he assumed was meaningful。 He held me in his embrace for a 
while�察 �then  the  ignoramus  said  the  following�此  �Were  you   ̄Saturday`  or 
^Wednesday¨�拭院�
^ ̄Wednesday` was the workshop name of the dearly departed for a time�察亜�I 
said。 He fell silent。 
The story behind these workshop names�察�which bound us to one another 
like  a  secret  pact�察 �was  simple�此 �During  our  apprenticeships�察 �when  Osman  the 
miniaturist had newly graduated from assistant master to the level of master�察�
we all shared a great respect�察�admiration and love for him。 He was a virtuoso 
and  he  taught  us  everything�察 �for  God  had  blessed  him  with  an  enchanting 
artistic gift and the intellect of a jinn。 Early each morning�察�as was demanded of 
apprentices�察 �one  of  us  would  go  to  the  master¨s  home�察 �and  following 
respectfully behind him on the way to the workshop�察�carry his pen and brush 
box�察�his bag and his portfolio full of papers。 So desperate were we to be near 
him that we¨d argue and fight among ourselves to determine who would go 
that day。 
Master Osman had a favorite。 But if he were always to go�察�it would fan the 
flames of the never´ending gossip and tasteless jokes that inevitably filled the 
workshop�察�and so the great master decided that each of us would be assured a 
specified day of the week。 The great master worked on Fridays and stayed at 
home Saturdays。 His son�察�whom he loved dearly!who later betrayed him and 
us  by  quitting  the  trade!would  acpany  his  father  on  Mondays  like  a 
mon  apprentice。  There  was  also  a  tall  thin  brother  of  ours  known  as 
^Thursday�察院 �a  miniaturist  more  gifted  than  any  of  us�察 �who  passed  away  at  a 
108 
 
young age�察�succumbing to the fever brought on by a mysterious illness。 Elegant 
Effendi�察 �may  he  rest  in  peace�察 �would  go  on  Wednesdays�察 �and  was  therefore 
known  as  ^Wednesday。 ̄  Later�察 �our  great  master  meaningfully  and  lovingly 
changed our names from ^Tuesday ̄ to ^Olive�察院�from ^Friday ̄ to ^Stork�察院�and 
from  ^Sunday ̄  to  ^Butterfly�察院 �renaming  the  dearly  departed  as  ^Elegant ̄  in 
allusion  to  the  finesse  of  his  gilding  work。  The  great  master  must  have  said�察�
^Wele  ̄Wednesday�察亜�how are you this morning�拭院�to the late Elegant just 
as he used to greet all of us back then。 
When  I  recalled  how  he  would  address  me�察 �I  thought  my  eyes  might  fill 
with tears�此�Master Osman admired us�察�and his own eyes would tear when he 
beheld the beauty of our work�察�he¨d kiss our hands and arms�察�and despite the 
beatings�察 �we  felt  as  if  we  were  in  Heaven  as  apprentices�察 �and  so  our  talent 
blossomed  with  his  love。  Even  jealousy�察 �which  cast  its  shadow  over  those 
happy years�察�had a different hue then。 
Now I am pletely divided�察�just like those figures whose head and hands 
are  drawn  and  painted  by  one  master  while  their  bodies  and  clothes  are 
depicted  by  another。  When  a  God´fearing  man  like  myself  unexpectedly 
bees a murderer�察�it takes time to adjust。 I¨ve adopted a second voice�察�one 
befitting  a  murderer�察 �so  that  I  might  still  carry  on  as  though  my  old  life 
continued。 I am speaking now in this derisive and devious second voice�察�which 
I  keep  out  of  my  regular  life。  From  time  to  time�察 �of  course�察 �you¨ll  hear  my 
familiar�察 �regular  voice�察 �which  would¨ve  remained  my  only  voice  had  I  not 
bee  a  murderer。  But  when  I  speak  under  my  workshop  name�察 �I¨ll  never 
admit  to  being  ^a  murderer。 ̄  Let  no  one  try  to  associate  these  two  voices�察 �I 
have  no  individual  style  or  flaws  in  artistry  to  betray  my  hidden  persona。 
Indeed�察 �I  believe  that  style�察 �or  for  that  matter�察 �anything  that  serves  to 
distinguish  one  artist  from  another�察 �is  a  flaw!not  individual  character�察 �as 
some arrogantly claim。 
I do admit that in my own situation�察�this presents a problem。 For though I 
might  speak  through  my  workshop  name�察 �lovingly  given  to  me  by  Master 
Osman and used by Enishte Effendi�察�who also admired it�察�in no wise do I want 
you  to  figure  out  whether  I  am  Butterfly�察 �Olive  or  Stork。  For  if  you  do  you 
won¨t hesitate to turn me over to the torturers of the Sultan¨s mander of 
the Imperial Guard。 
And�察�I must mind what I think about and say。 Actually�察�I know that you¨re 
listening to me even when I¨m mulling over matters in private。 I can¨t afford 
careless  contemplation  of  my  frustrations  or  the  incriminating  details  of  my 
109 
 
life。  Even  when  recounting  the  ^Alif�察院  �Ba ̄  and  ^Djim ̄  stories。  I  was  always 
mindful of your gaze。 
One  side  of  the  warriors�察 �lovers�察 �princes  and  legendary  heroes  that  I¨ve 
illustrated tens of thousands of times faces whatever is depicted there�察�in that 
mythical  time!the  enemies  they¨re  battling�察 �for  example�察 �or  the  dragons 
they¨re slaying�察�or the beautiful maidens over whom they weep。 But another 
aspect�察�and another side of their bodies�察�faces the book lover who happens to 
be gazing at the magnificent painting。 If I do have style and character�察�it¨s not 
only hidden in my artwork�察�but in my crime and in my words as well� �Yes�察�try 
to discover who I am from the color of my words� �
I�察 �too�察 �know  that  if  you  catch  me�察 �it¨ll  bring  consolation  to  unfortunate 
Elegant Effendi¨s miserable soul。 They¨re shoveling dirt on him as I stand here 
beneath trees�察�amid chirping birds�察�watching the gilded waters of the Golden 
Horn and the leaden domes of Istanbul�察�and discovering anew how wonderful 
it is to be alive。 Pathetic Elegant Effendi�察�soon after he joined the circle of that 
fierce´browed preacher from Erzurum�察�he stopped liking me pletely�察�yet�察�in 
the  twenty´five  years  that  we  illustrated  books  for  Our  Sultan�察 �there  were 
times  when  we  felt  very  close  to  each  other。  Twenty  years  ago�察 �we  became 
friends  while  working  on  a  royal  history  in  verse  for  the  late  father  of  our 
present  sultan。  But  we  were  never  closer  than  when  working  on  the  eight 
illustrated  plates  that  were  to  acpany  a  collection  of  Fuzuli  poems。  One 
summer evening back then�察�as a concession to his understandable but illogical 
desires!apparently  a  miniaturist  ought  to  feel  in  his  soul  the  text  he¨s 
illustrating!I  came  here  and  patiently  listened  to  him  pretentiously  recite 
lines from Fuzuli¨s collected works as flocks of swallows fluttered above us in a 
frenzy。 I still recall a line recited that evening�此 �I am not me but eternally thee。 ̄ 
I¨ve always wondered how one might illustrate this line。 
I ran to his house as soon as I learned that his body had been found。 There�察�
the diminutive garden where we once sat and recited poetry�察�now covered in 
snow�察�seemed diminished�察�just like any garden revisited after a period of years。 
His  house  was  that  way�察 �too。  From  the  next  room�察 �I  could  hear  the  wails  of 
women�察 �and  their  exaggerated  exclamations�察 �mounting  as  if  they  were 
peting with each other。 When his eldest brother spoke�察�I listened intently�此�
The face of our forlorn brother Elegant was practically destroyed�察�and his head 
was smashed。 After he was removed from the bottom of the well where he¨d 
lain for four days�察�his brothers scarcely knew him�察�and his poor wife�察�Kalbiye�察�
whom   they¨d   brought   from   the   house�察  �was   forced   to   identify   the 
unrecognizable body in the dark of night by its torn and tattered clothing。 I 
110 
 
was reminded of a depiction of the Midian merchants pulling Joseph from the 
pit  into  which  he¨d  been  cast  by  his  jealous  brothers。  I  quite  enjoy  painting 
this scene from the romance of Joseph and Zuleyha�察�for it reminds us that envy 
is the prime emotion in life。 
There was a sudden lull。 I sensed their eyes upon me。 Should I cry�拭�I caught 
Black¨s eye。 That vile scoundrel�察�he¨s peering at us�察�like someone who¨s been 
sent here by Enishte Effendi to uncover the truth。 
^Who  could¨ve  perpetrated  such  a  horrendous  crime�拭院 �cried  the  oldest 
brother。 ^What kind of heartless beast could¨ve slaughtered our brother�察�our 
brother who wouldn¨t dare harm an ant�拭院�
He  answered  this  question  with  his  own  tears�察 �and  I  joined  him�察 �feigning 
grief while I sought my own answer�此�Who were Elegant¨s enemies�拭�If it hadn¨t 
been me�察�who else could¨ve murdered him�拭�I recalled that some time ago!I 
believe  it  was  when  the  Book  of  Skills  was  being  prepared!he  would  get 
involved in arguments with certain artists inclined to dismiss the techniques 
of the old masters and ruin the pages we illustrators had labored extensively 
over�察 �thus  they  would  spoil  the  borders  with  the  horrid  colors  used  to 
embellish more cheaply and quickly。 Who were they�拭�Later�察�however�察�rumors 
began  to  spread  that  the  enmity  had  arisen  not  for  this  reason�察 �but  out  of 
petition for the affections of a handsome binder¨s apprentice who worked 
on the ground floor�察�but this was an old story。 And there were those who were 
annoyed  by  Elegant¨s  dignity�察 �his  refinement  and  his  erudite  feminine 
demeanor�察 �but  this  had  to  do  with  another  matter  entirely�此 �Elegant  was 
slavishly  bound  to  the  old  style�察 �a  fanatic  about  the  coordination  of  color 
between  gilding  and  illustration�察 �and  in  the  presence  of  Master  Osman�察 �he 
would�察�for instance�察�point out the nonexistent faults of other miniaturists!
mine  in  particular!with  gentle  conceit。  His  last  quarrel  had  to  do  with  an 
issue  about  which  Master  Osman  had�察 �in  past  years�察 �grown  quite  sensitive�此�
royal  miniaturists  who  moonlighted�察 �secretly  accepting  trivial  missions 
outside the auspices of the palace。 In recent years�察�after Our Sultan¨s interest 
had  begun  to  wane  and�察 �along  with  it�察 �the  money  ing  from  the  Head 
Treasurer�察�all the miniaturists started paying visits to the two´story houses of 
the crass young pashas!and the best of the artists would go late at night to 
visit Enishte。 
I wasn¨t at all bothered by Enishte¨s decision to stop working on his!on 
our!book  or  his  excuse  that  it  was  ill´omened。  He  had�察 �of  course�察 �guessed 
that the murderer who did away with brainless Elegant Effendi was one of us 
who were embellishing his book。 Put yourself in his shoes�此�Would you invite a 
111 
 
murderer  to  your  house  each  fortnight  to  work  on  illustrations  after  dark�拭�
Wouldn¨t  you  first  determine  the  identities  of  the  murderer  and  the  best 
illustrator�拭�I have no doubt that he¨ll quickly deduce which of the miniaturists 
was  the  most  talented  and  the  most  skilled  in  color  selection�察 �gilding�察 �page 
ruling�察 �illustration�察 �face  drawing  and  page  position�察 �and  having  done  so�察�
he¨ll continue working with me alone。 I can¨t imagine he¨ll be so petty as to 
think  of  me  as  a  mon  murderer  rather  than  a  genuinely  talented 
miniaturist。 
Out of the corner of my eye I am watching that fool Black Effendi whom 
Enishte  brought  with  him。  When  these  two  broke  away  from  the  cemetery 
crowd  presently  dispersing�察 �and  walked  down  to  the  Ey┨p  quay�察 �I  followed 
them。 They boarded a four´oared longboat�察�and afterward�察�I got into a six´oar 
along with a few young apprentices who¨d forgotten about the deceased and 
the  funeral  and  were  making  merry。  Within  sight  of  the  Phanar  Gate�察 �our 
boats momentarily came so near each other that they were about to lock oars�察�
and  I  could  see  clearly  that  Black  was  earnestly  whispering  to  Enishte。  I 
thereupon thought how easy it was to end a life。 My dear God�察�you¨ve given 
each of us this unbelievable power�察�but you¨ve also made us afraid to exercise 
it。 
Still�察 �if  a  man  but  once  overes  this  fear  and  acts�察 �he  straightaway 
bees  an  entirely  different  person。  There  was  a  time  when  I  was  terrified 
not  only  of  the  Devil�察 �but  of  the  slightest  trace  of  evil  within  me。  Now�察�
however�察 �I  have  the  sense  that  evil  can  be  endured�察 �and  moreover�察 �that  it¨s 
indispensable  to  an  artist。  After  I  killed  that  miserable  excuse  of  a  man�察�
discounting the trembling in my hands which lasted only a few days�察�I drew 
better�察�I made use of brighter and bolder colors�察�and most important�察�realized 
that  I  could  conjure  up  wonders  in  my  imagination。  But�察 �this  begs  the 
question how many men in Istanbul can truly appreciate the magnificence of 
my illustrations�拭�
Off the waterfront near Jibali�察�from all the way in the middle of the Golden 
Horn�察�I gazed spitefully at Istanbul。 The snow´capped domes shone bright in 
the  sunlight  that  broke  abruptly  through  the  clouds。  The  larger  and  more 
colorful  a  city  is�察 �the  more  places  there  are  to  hide  one¨s  guilt  and  sin�察 �the 
more crowded it is�察�the more people there are to hide behind。 A city¨s intellect 
ought to be measured not by its scholars�察�libraries�察�miniaturists�察�calligraphers 
and schools�察�but by the number of crimes insidiously mitted on its dark 
streets over thousands of years。 By this logic�察�doubtless�察�Istanbul is the world¨s 
most intelligent city。 
112 
 
At the Unkapan�拭�quay�察�I left my longboat a little after Black and his Enishte 
had left theirs。 I was behind them as they leaned on one another and mounted 
the  hill。  At  the  site  of  a  recent  fire  in  the  shadow  of  the  Sultan  Mehmet 
Mosque�察 �they  stopped  and  exchanged  parting  words。  Enishte  Effendi  was 
alone�察�and he appeared for an instant like a helpless old man。 I was tempted to 
run  to  him  and  tell  him  what  that  barbarian�察 �from  whose  funeral  w
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��1�� 家��2��
酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何!
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��